Russells kitchen is the highest-rated restaurant on Hayling Island on live Google data, with 5 stars from 75 reviews (checked 2026-09-28). Bronte’s Cafe is next.
We pulled the live Google rating, review count and (for food businesses) food hygiene rating for every restaurant on Hayling Island — covering West Beach, Beachlands, Mengham, North Hayling, Northney. We found 15 with enough of a track record to compare. Every figure below is correct as of 2026-09-28.
How we ranked them: highest Google star rating first, ties broken by review count. Restaurants with fewer than 15 reviews are listed after the rest, because a handful of reviews isn't a fair comparison against a business with hundreds. Nobody paid to be on this list, and nobody can pay to move up it.
| # | Name | Address | Reviews | Hygiene | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Russells kitchen | Dover Ct | 5 | 75 | 5 |
| 2 | Bronte’s Cafe | Havant Rd. | 4.9 | 88 | — |
| 3 | Isla Bay Seafront Kitchen | 6 Rails Ln | 4.7 | 313 | 5 |
| 4 | Mike’s Kitchen | 7 Mengham Rd | 4.7 | 128 | 5 |
| 5 | Elm Masala | 129 Elm Grove | 4.6 | 101 | — |
| 6 | Royal Edana Indian dining | 58 Hollow Ln | 4.6 | 32 | — |
| 7 | The Moghul Brasserie | 15-17 Elm Grove | 4.5 | 190 | 4 |
| 8 | Groves - Restaurant and Bar | 22 C | 4.5 | 139 | — |
| 9 | The Missing Squirrel | Mill Rythe Ln | 4.3 | 104 | — |
| 10 | Ferryboat Inn Hayling Island | Ferry Rd | 4.2 | 3066 | 5 |
| 11 | Inn on the Beach | 97 Sea Front | 4.2 | 2597 | 5 |
| 12 | Square Rigger Waterside Bar & Kitchen | Sparkes Marina | 4.2 | 566 | 5 |
| 13 | The Galleon Café Bar | Fishery Creek Caravan & Camping Park | 4.2 | 34 | 5 |
| 14 | Palms Bar Restaurant & Coffee Shop | Manor Rd | 4.1 | 53 | — |
| 15 | Hayling Grilled Chicken | 10 Rails Ln | 3.9 | 139 | 5 |
1Russells kitchen
★ 5 · 75 Google reviews · Dover Ct, Hayling Island PO11 0QX
Russells kitchen in Mengham holds 5★ from 75 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are loaded fries (18 reviews), burgers (29 reviews), smash burger (9 reviews), welcoming staff (4 reviews). Diners say this eatery offers amazing smash burgers made with fresh ingredients, delicious loaded fries, and a hearty breakfast. They also highlight the friendly and helpful staff. One reviewer wrote: “Best burger ever 😋 👌 😍 loaded fries with halloumi and jalapeños amazing 👏.” Food hygiene 5 (June 2025).
2Bronte’s Cafe
★ 4.9 · 88 Google reviews · Havant Rd., Hayling Island PO11 0LP
Bronte’s Cafe holds 4.9★ from 88 Google reviews. People say this cafe offers delicious coffee, a wide selection of homemade cakes, and superb toasties. They also highlight the friendly and welcoming staff, who provide excellent service. Others mention the great value for money and the picturesque views. One reviewer wrote: “Fresh food and homemade cakes delivered by very friendly owner and staff.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 07743 901930.
3Isla Bay Seafront Kitchen
★ 4.7 · 313 Google reviews · 6 Rails Ln, Hayling Island PO11 9LL
Isla Bay Seafront Kitchen holds 4.7★ from 313 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are dog friendly (13 reviews), poached eggs (9 reviews), outdoor seating (6 reviews), ham n cheese toastie (2 reviews). Diners like this cafe's delicious and high-quality food, including breakfast options like the Isla Bay breakfast, and a wide variety of hot drinks and cakes. They also highlight the generous portion sizes and the accommodating staff who provide excellent service. Visitors appreciate the friendly, welcoming, and relaxed atmosphere, as well as the cafe's dog-friendly policy. One reviewer wrote: “Fabulous food ,very attentive staff spotlessly clean ,try the burger 10/10.” Food hygiene 5 (June 2025). Phone 023 9217 8536.
4Mike’s Kitchen
★ 4.7 · 128 Google reviews · 7 Mengham Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9BG
Mike’s Kitchen in Mengham holds 4.7★ from 128 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are bacon bap (3 reviews), sausage roll (2 reviews), outdoor seating (5 reviews), quality produce (6 reviews). Diners like this cafe's delicious, freshly cooked food, including generous breakfast portions and homemade cakes, with many highlighting the quality ingredients. They also mention the spotless environment and the friendly, attentive staff who provide excellent service. Guests appreciate the calm, lovely atmosphere and the reasonable prices. One reviewer wrote: “Good quality ingredients made for nice meals and friendly service.” Food hygiene 5 (May 2025). Phone 023 9246 0560.
5Elm Masala
★ 4.6 · 101 Google reviews · 129 Elm Grove, Hayling Island PO11 9ED
Elm Masala holds 4.6★ from 101 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are curry (16 reviews), chicken tikka masala (4 reviews), naan bread (2 reviews), friendly staff (23 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “Really excellent curry house at very reasonable prices.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 023 9234 1483.
6Royal Edana Indian dining
★ 4.6 · 32 Google reviews · 58 Hollow Ln, Hayling Island PO11 9EY
Royal Edana Indian dining holds 4.6★ from 32 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are curries (4 reviews), generous portions (4 reviews), naan (2 reviews), welcoming staff (4 reviews). Diners like this restaurant's delicious Indian cuisine, noting the authentic flavors, generous portions, and variety of dishes. They also highlight the warm, welcoming atmosphere and the friendly, attentive staff who provide excellent service. One reviewer wrote: “I would recommend this as the best indian on Hayling, staff are so friendly.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 023 9246 0621.
7The Moghul Brasserie
★ 4.5 · 190 Google reviews · 15-17 Elm Grove, Hayling Island PO11 9EA
The Moghul Brasserie holds 4.5★ from 190 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are buffet (51 reviews), all you can eat buffet (3 reviews), buffet nights (4 reviews), quick turnaround (2 reviews). Diners like this restaurant's delicious buffet, which offers a good selection of hot and mild dishes, and they appreciate the option to refill their plates. They also highlight the friendly family atmosphere and the excellent service. Others mention the reasonable prices and the quick delivery for takeaways. One reviewer wrote: “Favourite Indian restaurant... Good food great atmosphere and ...” Food hygiene 4 (December 2025). Phone 023 9246 3200.
8Groves - Restaurant and Bar
★ 4.5 · 139 Google reviews · 22 C, 22C Elm Grove, Hayling Island PO11 9EF
Groves - Restaurant and Bar holds 4.5★ from 139 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are gin selection (3 reviews), sunday roasts (2 reviews), tapas (7 reviews), welcoming staff (3 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “We had a lovely evening with a great impromptu sharing platter.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 023 9246 7877.
9The Missing Squirrel
★ 4.3 · 104 Google reviews · Mill Rythe Ln, Hayling Island PO11 0PB
The Missing Squirrel holds 4.3★ from 104 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are kids (9 reviews), sunday roast (2 reviews), vegan option (3 reviews), cocktail bar (2 reviews). Diners like this restaurant's great food, wide variety of drinks, and excellent cocktails. They also highlight the friendly, helpful staff and the pleasant atmosphere. Some reviews mention the service can be slow. One reviewer wrote: “Lovely food served by Larna who was very attentive with our group.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 0330 053 7000.
10Ferryboat Inn Hayling Island
★ 4.2 · 3066 Google reviews · Ferry Rd, Hayling Island PO11 0DG
Ferryboat Inn Hayling Island holds 4.2★ from 3066 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are sunset views (23 reviews), fish and chips (82 reviews), harbour view (23 reviews), beach (49 reviews). People say this pub offers delicious and fresh food, including excellent fish and chips, roasts, and a varied menu with seafood options. They also highlight the stunning views, friendly staff, and welcoming atmosphere, noting it's dog-friendly and has ample parking. Some reviews mention the service can be inattentive. One reviewer wrote: “Not great for food but pleasant atmosphere and views across sea.” Food hygiene 5 (July 2024). Phone 023 9200 8339.
11Inn on the Beach
★ 4.2 · 2597 Google reviews · 97 Sea Front, Hayling Island PO11 0AS
Inn on the Beach holds 4.2★ from 2597 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are fish and chips (118 reviews), sea views (85 reviews), sunday roast (36 reviews), beachfront location (29 reviews). People say this pub offers delicious food, including fresh fish and chips, mussels, and hearty roasts, with generous portions. They also highlight the stunning sea views, friendly staff, and welcoming atmosphere. Some reviews mention the service can be slow. One reviewer wrote: “Had a splendid meal in a really nice setting with great service.” Food hygiene 5 (June 2025). Phone 023 9246 0043.
12Square Rigger Waterside Bar & Kitchen
★ 4.2 · 566 Google reviews · Sparkes Marina, 38 Wittering Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9SR
Square Rigger Waterside Bar & Kitchen holds 4.2★ from 566 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are marina view (14 reviews), cocktails (50 reviews), squid (7 reviews), outdoor seating (10 reviews). Diners like this restaurant's delicious and high-quality food, especially the fresh seafood, and appreciate the varied menu with generous portions. They also highlight the friendly and attentive staff, the relaxed atmosphere, and the beautiful waterfront views. Some reviews mention the service can be slow. One reviewer wrote: “Great food great service great value nice atmosphere what's not to like.” Food hygiene 5 (May 2024). Phone 023 9400 2555.
13The Galleon Café Bar
★ 4.2 · 34 Google reviews · Fishery Creek Caravan & Camping Park, 100 Fishery Ln, Hayling Island PO11 9NR
The Galleon Café Bar in Mengham holds 4.2★ from 34 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are mushrooms (2 reviews), fries (2 reviews), beans (2 reviews), atmosphere (2 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “Excellent foo, reasonably priced and lovely atmosphere.” Food hygiene 5 (March 2026). Phone 07928 486922.
14Palms Bar Restaurant & Coffee Shop
★ 4.1 · 53 Google reviews · Manor Rd, Hayling Island PO11 0QS
Palms Bar Restaurant & Coffee Shop holds 4.1★ from 53 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are kids entertainment (2 reviews), decor (3 reviews), sausages (2 reviews), friendly staff (12 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “We had 2 really great meals here over 2 days and were a medium size party.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register.
15Hayling Grilled Chicken
★ 3.9 · 139 Google reviews · 10 Rails Ln, Hayling Island PO11 9LL
Hayling Grilled Chicken in Mengham holds 3.9★ from 139 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are friendly staff (36 reviews), chilli cheese bites (2 reviews), chicken fillet burger (2 reviews), wings (6 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “Great place friendly service, and great food, always met with a smile.” Food hygiene 5 (June 2025). Phone 023 9246 0666.
The verdict
For the best restaurant on Hayling Island on the numbers, it's Russells kitchen — 5★ from 75 Google reviews. Bronte’s Cafe (4.9★, 88 reviews) is close behind.
Run one we've missed? Tell us and we'll check it and add it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best restaurant on Hayling Island?
On live Google ratings, Russells kitchen is the highest-rated, with 5 stars from 75 reviews (as of 2026-09-28). Bronte’s Cafe is close behind.
How many restaurants are there on Hayling Island?
We found 15 restaurants on Hayling Island with a live Google listing and at least one review, across West Beach, Beachlands, Mengham, North Hayling, Northney.
Does Russells kitchen have a good food hygiene rating?
Yes — Food hygiene 5 (June 2025), according to the Food Standards Agency register.