Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island is the highest-rated pizza place on Hayling Island on live Google data, with 4.9 stars from 123 reviews (checked 2026-09-28). Reeko's pizza is next.
We pulled the live Google rating, review count and (for food businesses) food hygiene rating for every pizza place on Hayling Island — covering West Beach, Beachlands, Mengham, North Hayling, Northney. We found 6 with enough of a track record to compare. Every figure below is correct as of 2026-09-28.
How we ranked them: highest Google star rating first, ties broken by review count. Pizza Places with fewer than 15 reviews are listed after the rest, because a handful of reviews isn't a fair comparison against a business with hundreds. Nobody paid to be on this list, and nobody can pay to move up it.
| # | Name | Address | Reviews | Hygiene | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island | 26A Elm Grove | 4.9 | 123 | — |
| 2 | Reeko's pizza | Mill Rythe Ln | 4.8 | 53 | 5 |
| 3 | Kebab Pizza Planet | 28b Station Rd | 4.6 | 317 | 5 |
| 4 | Island Kebab | 3 Station Rd | 4.4 | 50 | 5 |
| 5 | Hayling Pizza | 11 Southwood Rd | 4.2 | 70 | 5 |
| 6 | Domino's Pizza - Hayling Island | 31 Elm Grove | 4 | 66 | 5 |
1Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island
★ 4.9 · 123 Google reviews · 26A Elm Grove, Hayling Island PO11 9EF
Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island holds 4.9★ from 123 Google reviews. People say this takeaway offers delicious, fresh, and homemade pizzas and burgers, with generous portions and flavorful toppings. They also highlight the reasonable prices, fast delivery, and excellent service from the friendly and attentive staff. One reviewer wrote: “Perfectly baked crust, rich sauce, and fresh, flavorful toppings.” Hygiene rating: not found on the FSA register. Phone 023 9216 1234.
2Reeko's pizza
★ 4.8 · 53 Google reviews · Mill Rythe Ln, Hayling Island PO11 0QG
Reeko's pizza holds 4.8★ from 53 Google reviews. Diners say this restaurant offers delicious, authentic wood-fired pizzas and amazing, well-seasoned burgers and chips. They also highlight the decent prices and the friendly, accommodating staff. Others mention the cool, welcoming vibe and the passion put into the food. One reviewer wrote: “Great pizza...the best wood fired in the area and consistently open.” Food hygiene 5 (April 2025). Phone 07542 969273.
3Kebab Pizza Planet
★ 4.6 · 317 Google reviews · 28b Station Rd, West Town, Hayling Island PO11 0EG
Kebab Pizza Planet holds 4.6★ from 317 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are chicken shish (10 reviews), donner kebabs (4 reviews), lamb kebabs (3 reviews), succulent meat (4 reviews). People say this takeaway offers delicious and fresh kebabs, including chicken and lamb, with generous portion sizes. They also highlight the quick delivery and the food arriving hot. Others mention the friendly and polite staff, as well as the convenient free parking. One reviewer wrote: “The pizza was here before schedule, was nice and hot and delicious.” Food hygiene 5 (August 2026). Phone 023 9246 3626.
4Island Kebab
★ 4.4 · 50 Google reviews · 3 Station Rd, Hayling Island PO11 0EA
Island Kebab holds 4.4★ from 50 Google reviews. Diners say this kebab shop offers delicious and fresh food, including flavorful chicken doner and homemade garlic and chili sauces. They also highlight the great value, friendly staff, and fast delivery service. Some reviews mention that orders can be incorrect. One reviewer wrote: “the flavours and the cheese they used was perfect.” Food hygiene 5 (January 2026). Phone 023 9246 6002.
5Hayling Pizza
★ 4.2 · 70 Google reviews · 11 Southwood Rd, Hayling Island PO11 9PS
Hayling Pizza holds 4.2★ from 70 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are portion size (5 reviews), value for money (2 reviews), kebabs (10 reviews), fresh food (4 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “Pizza was delicious, full of flavour, not greasy.” Food hygiene 5 (June 2024). Phone 023 9307 8901.
6Domino's Pizza - Hayling Island
★ 4 · 66 Google reviews · 31 Elm Grove, Hayling Island PO11 9EA
Domino's Pizza - Hayling Island holds 4★ from 66 Google reviews. The most-mentioned points in reviews are kind staff (2 reviews), online ordering (3 reviews), cleanliness (4 reviews), atmosphere (2 reviews). One reviewer wrote: “Great tasting pizza, and amazing value.” Food hygiene 5 (July 2024). Phone 023 9437 3737.
The verdict
For the best pizza place on Hayling Island on the numbers, it's Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island — 4.9★ from 123 Google reviews. Reeko's pizza (4.8★, 53 reviews) is close behind.
Run one we've missed? Tell us and we'll check it and add it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best pizza place on Hayling Island?
On live Google ratings, Beast Feast Pizza Hayling Island is the highest-rated, with 4.9 stars from 123 reviews (as of 2026-09-28). Reeko's pizza is close behind.
How many pizza places are there on Hayling Island?
We found 6 pizza places on Hayling Island with a live Google listing and at least one review, across West Beach, Beachlands, Mengham, North Hayling, Northney.